If you were stranded alone on a deserted island would it be safer to drink sea water or your own urine?

satguru

No doubt about this one. Drinking healthy urine is used in many places as a cure, has no germs and shouldn't do you any harm. It won't be so good on its own as will be too strong compared to normal water but I don't know how long you'll manage on it. http://www.shirleys-wellness-cafe.com/urine.htm Sea water, however, is pretty well undrinkable and better to avoid totally. Aug 16 05, 5:07 PM

hotpinky

Correct satguru! Although I have never enjoyed a good strong cup of my own pee, as your site seems to recomend, I do know that all the salt in sea water serves only to make a person even thirstier if drunk. Aug 16 05, 8:12 PM

monketteyax

Actually, you wouldn't be much better off drinking your urine. The reason you're not supposed to drink salt water is because of its high solute concentrations, especially salt. Your body "wants" to get rid of the extra salt that you have just put in it, so it does that through your urine. This is a problem, though, because due to osmotic pulls (osmosis = movement of water, ie from areas of low solute conentration to high solute concentration), water "wants" to move into the extremely solute concentrated area, ie your pee. So you end up loosing more water than you actually gain, and end up dying of dehydration because your body cells have lost so much water. Drinking urine might be better, but you still face the above problem, although probably not to the same degree as sea water. Another problem you might face is the microbes (ie, bacteria, viruses, fungi) that you might end up ingesting from sea water, and probably from your own pee. I might take my chances with the pee over the sea water, mind you. And there you have it! Your best solution is probably to find a source of fresh water, or collect rain...it's the "healthiest" choice in this situation, if you don't want to die of self-induced dehydration. Glad that degree in Biology was good for something....:) Feb 01 07, 10:48 AM

Create a Free FunTrivia ID to add to, request more/new answers, or edit this entry

How Long were the castaways stranded on Gilligans Island? Is there any scientific proof that drinking your own urine actually has some positive effects? Why is it so dangerous for people adrift in the ocean to drink sea water? Is it true that as soon as you die, you release all the urine and feces in your body?

1 Would you survive on Harper's Island? Watch out for mistakes that characters have made throughout the show that resulted in their demise, or the demise of another. Your answers will ultimately decide whether or not you'd live if you were placed on the island and faced similar scenarios. Harper's Island Difficult 10 Q colcot Jul 09 09 258 plays 2 Stranded on "The Island" "The Island": an intense, action-packed thriller with many fantastic elements. As our main characters try to escape from their cloning grounds, they fight the corporation's bounty hunters - and the corporation itself. Island, The Average 10 Q caocao14 Aug 02 09 105 plays 3 "You Are Not Your Own" by Jason Perry This is a quiz about my favorite book ever. Hope you enjoy it. P Very Difficult 10 Q Christiansingerinlove Jan 19 03 87 plays