Quizzes at Fun Trivia Fun Trivia | quizzes Quizzes | games Games | community People | services Services | help Help | me Me
New Player - Log In
Currently 5906 players online.   Trivia games, quizzes, and contests - FREE !     Get Started! quiz register


  • New Questions

  • Unanswered

  • Revisited

  • Your Questions


  • Post a Question
  • Goto Qn #



    110,575 questions asked
    381,964 replies


    Archives

    Why Achilles' heel but Dickens's novels? Why s' and s's for names ending in s?

    Question #61965. Asked by loominitsa.

    lanfranco

    Well, according to my Modern Language Association Handbook, only one-syllable proper names ending in "s" should have an apostrophe and another "s" added -- "Keats's poems." Polysyllabic names ending in "s" should take only an apostrophe for the possessive: "Cervantes' books, Hopkins' poems." The MLA would thus prefer "Dickens' books."

    However, the Chicago Manual of Style states that while both "Dickens'" and "Dickens's" are correct, the CMS prefers the latter.

    So take your pick.

    Jan 24 06, 4:51 PM
    satguru

    I've also seen official literature with Ellises and the like, and tend to see all three versions used almost at will. While I'm here I also just heard the old possesive form of it was its' (as opposed to it's, an abbreviation).

    Apostrophes appear to be part of a developing rather than a fixed grammar!

    Jan 24 06, 7:51 PM
    lanfranco

    When I first began teaching, I saw "its'" regularly. When I asked students what they meant by it, they often said, "Oh, that's the possessive plural of "its."

    "Its" does not have a possessive plural. "It," by definition, is always singular.

    Its = the possessive of "it": "Its color is red."

    It's = a contraction (not an abbreviation), meaning "it is" or "it has": "It's a book with a with a red cover."

    Its' = nothing. There is no such word.

    Jan 24 06, 8:23 PM
    McGruff

    I believe either way is considered correct, but here's what I found online:

    • add 's to the singular form of the word (even if it ends in -s):
    the owner's car
    James's hat

    • add 's to the plural forms that do not end in -s:
    the children's game
    the geese's honking

    • add ' to the end of plural nouns that end in -s:
    houses' roofs
    three friends' letters

    • add 's to the end of compound words:
    my brother-in-law's money

    • add 's to the last noun to show joint possession of an object:
    Todd and Anne's apartment

    http://owl.english.purdue.edu/handouts/grammar/g_apost.html

    Jan 24 06, 11:46 PM
    McGruff

    And I'm with Frankie, have never known its' to be correct, and further down the page at the site I provided earlier it agrees:

    Don't use apostrophes for possessive pronouns or for noun plurals.

    Apostrophes should not be used with possessive pronouns because possessive pronouns already show possession -- they don't need an apostrophe. His, her, its, my, yours, ours are all possessive pronouns.

    Jan 24 06, 11:51 PM
    satguru

    Until a few days ago its' was not heard of by me either, but on a radio programme a few boffins insisted it was used some time ago but died out (not in my memory either). But I agree if ours etc have no apostrophe, why should its? But I'll look around now for more details as the people seemed to know something about it.

    So far: McGruff 1 Satguru 0
    http://www.apostrophe.fsnet.co.uk/

    Jan 25 06, 9:46 AM
    McGruff

    Keeping score?

    I suppose it's possible that its' may have been used at some time before our time and either didn't catch on or fell out of favour. And I'd have to add that its' would be preferable to me over it's when being used incorrectly as the possessive pronoun because I've had it drilled into me that it's can only mean "it is." I had one really mean English teacher in elementary school.

    Jan 25 06, 10:05 AM

    Create a Free FunTrivia ID to add to, request more/new answers, or edit this entry

    Other Similar Questions & Answers


    Why is a dance noted for its fast heel-work named after a bird which famously spends most of the day standing on one leg?

    Which road was laid with the help of the romantic novels of Mills and Boon and why were their works chosen?

    When the Nazis established what was in effect a foreign legion, why were these units, consisting of nationalities and groups such Ukrainians, Latvians and Bosnian Muslims, put in the SS, notorious for its obsession with race, instead of in the regular armed forces, the 'Wehrmacht'?

    Why don't they give blizzards names like they do with hurricanes?

    Suggested Related FunTrivia Quizzes - 90,000 currently online

    1 The SS
    A quiz about the Third Reich's most fanatical military organization.
    European War Difficult
    10 Q
    pattons3rd
    Jul 16 06
    1020 plays
    2 Achilles on Scyros
    The tale of the Iliadic Achilles is common knowledge but the events on Scyros told in Statius' "Achilleid" are less well-known.
    Achilles Difficult
    10 Q
    genovia12
    Jun 21 08
    345 plays
    3 Novels of the Rigante: Soul-Names and Geasas
    David Gemmell wrote four 'Novels of the Rigante', throughout which characters not only have birth names, but also soul-names. Can you identify the character with the soul-name?
    Gemmell, David Average
    10 Q
    Pariah
    Oct 02 02
    438 plays


    "Ask FunTrivia" is for entertainment purposes only, and answers offered are unverified and unchecked by FunTrivia. We cannot guarantee the accuracy or veracity of ANY statement posted. Feel free to post an updated response if you feel that an answer is inadequate or incorrect. Please thoroughly research items where accuracy is important to you using multiple reliable sources. By accessing our website, you agree to be bound by our terms of service.