Register - Log In


FunTrivia Homepage



  • New Questions

  • Unanswered


  • Post a Question
  • Goto Qn #





    Archives

    Which Beatles song had a different drummer on the second pressing? Who was the drummer on the second pressing?

    Question #69019. Asked by teash. (Jul 30 06 8:17 AM)


    gtho4

    The original release of the single "Love Me Do" had Ringo Starr playing drums. It was subsequently released with drums played by Andy White, a studio drummer.

    The initial recording, released on October 5, 1962 in England, was recorded on September 4, 1962, in a fifteen-take session. It would not be before fifteen takes were performed that George Martin was basically satisfied, but not entirely. Returning to the studio one week later, The Beatles discovered that George Martin had a session drummer there by the name of Andy White who was to replace Ringo. Since Ringo had only recently replaced Pete Best, I feel sure he thought his days were numbered as well. Per Martin's decision, White played the drums on this retake, while Ringo stood by and played the tambourine. The initial recording with Ringo on the drums was the one that appeared on the single. But, for reasons that are not clear, Martin decided to use the Andy White drum version on this album. Whether he preferred White's drumming on this number to Ringo's is not clear, but Martin did say that he used White's version on the album because the master tape of this song had been sent overseas to an EMI subsidiary company. By mistake? Who knows. Additionally, later in 1963, all future single releases of Love Me Do was the retake version with Andy White.

    http://www.iamthebeatles.com/article1213.html

    http://www.iamthebeatles.com/article1213.html">http://www.iamthebeatles.com/article1213.html

    Jul 30 06, 9:32 AM

    BungeeAZ

    The original version of Love Me Do cut at EMI studios had Pete Best on it. It appears on Anthology I. You can hear Pete's limitations as a drummer on it. Due to this recording, George Martin decided that if the Beatles were to record quality material, the group would need a drummer for the studio, if they wanted to continue to use Pete on the road, they could do so, but George Martin did not want him behind the kit.

    In response to this, John, Paul and George told their manager, Brian Epstein, to fire Pete from the band. (there may have been other petty issues at play here as well).

    John went to where Rory Storm was playing in order to make a play for Ringo. After Ringo finished his obligations to Rory (a stand up thing to do, indeed), he joined the Beatles at EMI for a second take on Love Me Do; only to find that George Martin had hired Alan White (who would later join Yes) as the session drummer. Ringo played Tamborine on the single.

    Once George found out that Ringo could keep good time and was a good drummer, George never brought an outside musician in to play drums. Paul McCartney, not an outside musician, did play drums on a few tracks such as Back in the USSR.

    Jul 30 06, 10:06 AM


    Find something useful here? Please help us spread the word about FunTrivia. Recommend this page below!


    Sign up to see all responses!

    Create a Free ID instantly to see all recent responses, post your own follow-ups or questions, and access over 1,000,000 trivia questions!

    Choose a User Name:
    Your Email Address:
    Choose a Password:

    I agree by the terms outlined in FunTrivia's Conditions of Use





    Other Similar Questions & Answers


    Who was the drummer on The Beatles song "Love Me Do?"

    What noted drummer was the former drummer for Rory Storm and the Hurricanes?

    Who was the original drummer for the Beatles?

    Suggested Related FunTrivia Quizzes - 90,000 currently online

    1 The Beatles
    This quiz will test your knowlege of the greatest band of all time.
    Beatles, The Tough
    10 Q
    Patm
    Sep 26 02
    8310 plays
    2 The Beatles
    This is a very simple quiz about the Beatles.
    Beatles, The Average
    10 Q
    uga76
    Nov 24 04
    5946 plays
    3 The Beatles 1
    This is a quiz on The Beatles. The questions will get more difficult as you progress.
    Beatles, The Difficult
    10 Q
    snowconeboy789
    Sep 26 10
    1284 plays




    "Ask FunTrivia" is for entertainment purposes only, and answers offered are unverified and unchecked by FunTrivia. We cannot guarantee the accuracy or veracity of ANY statement posted. Feel free to post an updated response if you feel that an answer is inadequate or incorrect. Please thoroughly research items where accuracy is important to you using multiple reliable sources. By accessing our website, you agree to be bound by our terms of service.