If you guys ever need a set of criteria for a new badgelet, I think I may have stumbled across one today. After I saw my scores for the day, I had quite a hearty laugh because I've often said, "I may not be good, but I'm consistent."
"Deja Vu" or "Stuck in a Rut":
Achieve the exact same score in the daily "Team Heroes" and "Team vs Team games" (subject to some minimum score, because 0 & 0 isn't horribly interesting).