FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
Quiz about Ireland From Treaty to Civil War
Quiz about Ireland From Treaty to Civil War

Ireland: From Treaty to Civil War Quiz


The Anglo-Irish Treaty of 1921 was at least partly responsible for the civil war which followed in 1922. Here we examine the events dating from the treaty in the build up to the civil war.

A multiple-choice quiz by yavemiel. Estimated time: 6 mins.
  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Quizzes
  4. »
  5. History Trivia
  6. »
  7. European
  8. »
  9. Irish

Author
yavemiel
Time
6 mins
Type
Multiple Choice
Quiz #
291,284
Updated
Dec 03 21
# Qns
10
Difficulty
Tough
Avg Score
5 / 10
Plays
567
Awards
Top 35% Quiz
Last 3 plays: Guest 65 (8/10), Guest 217 (8/10), callie_ross (1/10).
- -
Question 1 of 10
1. When the treaty delegation returned to Ireland, the cabinet voted on whether or not to put the treaty to the Dáil. Can you name the three cabinet members who voted against this motion? Hint


Question 2 of 10
2. The treaty was put to the Dáil and was officially ratified by a narrow margin. What was that margin? Hint


Question 3 of 10
3. The debate on the treaty in the Dáil was heated, and as the narrow margin of victory shows, opinion was fairly evenly split. However, there was one small group who voted en bloc against the treaty. Who were they? Hint


Question 4 of 10
4. On the 10th January 1922, de Valera led his anti-treaty followers out of the Dáil, a move strongly criticised both at the time and in subsequent analysis of the conflict. Why was the move so strongly criticised? Hint


Question 5 of 10
5. Despite the withdrawal of anti-treaty T.D.s, the pro-treaty members of government who remained went ahead and formed a government regardless. Who was the president of that first government? Hint


Question 6 of 10
6. With the political split a fait accompli, the next organisation to undergo a schism was the I.R.A. In March 1922, Richard Mulcahy arranged a convention for I.R.A. members in an attempt to preserve unity. Why did he cancel it? Hint


Question 7 of 10
7. The next major step on the road to civil war came when a small group of anti-treaty I.R.A. members, led by Rory O' Connor, took over an important building in Dublin. Which building did they occupy? Hint


Question 8 of 10
8. Meanwhile, on the political front, the divide between pro- and anti-treaty politicians continued to widen. After increasing bitterness in pre-election campaigning, Collins and de Valera made a pact that neither of them would attempt to persuade the public to vote specifically for pro- or anti-treaty candidates. Which man broke the pact? Hint


Question 9 of 10
9. Though they had granted Irish independence, the British government still kept a close eye on Irish affairs, and they were worried about the position which the anti-Treaty I.R.A. held in Dublin. However, it was not until the murder of an ex-British army officer that they intervened. What was the name of the man shot dead by two I.R.A. members? Hint


Question 10 of 10
10. His hand forced by the threat of British intervention, Collins demanded that the anti-treaty garrison in Dublin surrender immediately. When they refused, he ordered the army to open fire, which they did, thereby starting the civil war. In which month of 1922 did these events transpire? Hint



(Optional) Create a Free FunTrivia ID to save the points you are about to earn:

arrow Select a User ID:
arrow Choose a Password:
arrow Your Email:




Most Recent Scores
Mar 19 2024 : Guest 65: 8/10
Feb 19 2024 : Guest 217: 8/10
Feb 14 2024 : callie_ross: 1/10

Score Distribution

quiz
Quiz Answer Key and Fun Facts
1. When the treaty delegation returned to Ireland, the cabinet voted on whether or not to put the treaty to the Dáil. Can you name the three cabinet members who voted against this motion?

Answer: Eamon de Valera, Austin Stack, Cathal Brugha

The motion was passed by four votes to three. The four cabinet ministers who voted for the motion were W.T. Cosgrave, Arthur Griffith, Michael Collins and Robert Barton. Stack and Brugha were die-hard republicans who rejected the treaty on principle and de Valera was also opposed to the references to the British monarch. Furthermore, he was annoyed with Collins and Griffith for not referring back to him in Dublin before signing the Treaty.

This exacerbated the personal enmity between de Valera and Collins, and their rivalry was to prove detrimental to Irish peace in the coming months.
2. The treaty was put to the Dáil and was officially ratified by a narrow margin. What was that margin?

Answer: 7 votes

The treaty was passed by 64 votes to 57, after prolonged and bitter debates in the Dáil, which did nothing to lessen the ill-feeling between the two sides. After the results of the vote were made public, de Valera and the anti-Treaty T.D.s rejected the result and left the Dáil in protest.

This move was a major step on the road to civil war, especially given the inflammatory speeches de Valera made after his withdrawal, in which he stated that "the majority has no right to do wrong" and that to get an Irish republic, it might be necessary to "wade through rivers of Irish blood".

A direct allusion to civil war? Possibly, though we will never know for certain if de Valera meant it as such.
3. The debate on the treaty in the Dáil was heated, and as the narrow margin of victory shows, opinion was fairly evenly split. However, there was one small group who voted en bloc against the treaty. Who were they?

Answer: All female T.D.s

While there were not many female T.D.s in the Dáil, all of them voted against the treaty as they felt that it betrayed the memories of the martyrs of the 1916 Rising. Some of them had very personal feelings regarding the 1916 martyrs; for example, the Countess Markiewicz had actually participated in the Rising.

Many of the other women suffered losses during the War of Independence, for example, Mary MacSwiney's brother Terence (the Lord Mayor of Cork at the time) died on hunger strike in protest at the British occupation in Ireland.

The previous Lord Mayor of Cork was murdered by British troops in his own home.
4. On the 10th January 1922, de Valera led his anti-treaty followers out of the Dáil, a move strongly criticised both at the time and in subsequent analysis of the conflict. Why was the move so strongly criticised?

Answer: All of these reasons are correct.

All of these factors contributed to the criticism which was heaped on de Valera after he left the Dáil. For a start, it was a very undemocratic move. Ireland had just gained independence from Britain and was supposed to be establishing itself as a democratic power.

Instead, when things did not go the way de Valera wanted, he backed out of government, instead of staying as the opposition party (as would have happened in a true democracy). Furthermore, de Valera's decision to leave the Dáil gave political credibility to the anti-treaty I.R.A. members. Without this, it is entirely possible that public opinion (which was far more in favour of the treaty than the tight vote in the Dáil showed) would have quashed these rebels into submission, but with de Valera's backing, the anti-treaty republicans were given an endorsement which enabled them to sway followers in the general public. Would the I.R.A. have split if de Valera had stayed in the Dáil? We will never know, but it is certain that his withdrawal added to the rising tension between the rival factions.
5. Despite the withdrawal of anti-treaty T.D.s, the pro-treaty members of government who remained went ahead and formed a government regardless. Who was the president of that first government?

Answer: Arthur Griffith

Arthur Griffith was elected President of the Cabinet, a position which would be equivalent to Taoiseach in modern Irish politics. Michael Collins was the Minister for Finance, though he felt he would have been better suited to defence. The Minister for Defence was in fact Richard Mulcahy, a staunch I.R.A. leader. Mulcahy survived the Civil War to become a prominent figure in Irish politics, at one point becoming the leader of the Fine Gael party, the direct descendant of Cumann na Gaedhal (the pro-treaty section of what was formerly Sinn Féin). W.T. Cosgrave was the Minister for Local Government.

Another Civil War survivor, Cosgrave was also a prominent figure in Irish politics, his most notable achievement being the manner in which he conducted himself during his tenure as President of the Cabinet from 1922 to 1932, during which time he attempted to bring stability back to the Irish people.
6. With the political split a fait accompli, the next organisation to undergo a schism was the I.R.A. In March 1922, Richard Mulcahy arranged a convention for I.R.A. members in an attempt to preserve unity. Why did he cancel it?

Answer: It became apparent that most I.R.A. members were opposed to the treaty.

This convention was a last ditch effort to halt the inevitable. However, Mulcahy realised soon after arranging the convention that it was futile to attempt to prevent the split going ahead, and he was afraid that violence might erupt if pro and anti-treaty sides were brought together in the same location.

However, despite the fact that Mulcahy cancelled the meeting, anti-treaty members of the I.R.A. met anyway under the leadership of Rory O' Connor and Liam Mellows. They made a vow never to accept the treaty, and at the same time, the government were busy forming an Irish Free State army from the ranks of the pro-treaty I.R.A. Thus the split in the organisation was complete and irreversible.
7. The next major step on the road to civil war came when a small group of anti-treaty I.R.A. members, led by Rory O' Connor, took over an important building in Dublin. Which building did they occupy?

Answer: The Four Courts

The occupation of the Four Courts by anti-treaty I.R.A. forces took place on the 14th April 1922. As the government were occupied with building the Free State army at the time, they mostly ignored the move, though they did keep tabs on the actions of the forces within the building.

The occupation of the Four Courts lasted approximately two months, and is regarded as a major factor in the build up to the civil war: if it had never happened, it is possible that the British government would not have forced the Irish government to make a move against the rebels.
8. Meanwhile, on the political front, the divide between pro- and anti-treaty politicians continued to widen. After increasing bitterness in pre-election campaigning, Collins and de Valera made a pact that neither of them would attempt to persuade the public to vote specifically for pro- or anti-treaty candidates. Which man broke the pact?

Answer: Collins.

The general election was due to take place soon after the treaty was ratified in the Dáil. However, due to the growing tension between the two sides, it was decided that the election should be postponed until the summer. This move has been widely criticised by historians since, as it is felt that if the general election had taken place straight away and the feelings of the general public had been made known immediately, it might have averted the Civil War.

As it was, tension continued to build between the opposing factions - and in particular between Collins and de Valera - until they decided to make the pact to avoid swaying the decision of the public. De Valera kept the pact, but Collins broke it two days before the June election, urging the people to vote for pro-treaty candidates.

The results of the election were decisive: Pro-treaty Sinn Féin won 58 seats, anti-treaty won 35, and all the other parties and the independents won 35 seats between them. All parties (bar the anti-treaty forces) supported the treaty, and it was obvious that the Irish public in general supported the treaty.

However, it was too little, too late, and the start of the Civil War a mere 10 days later was inevitable.
9. Though they had granted Irish independence, the British government still kept a close eye on Irish affairs, and they were worried about the position which the anti-Treaty I.R.A. held in Dublin. However, it was not until the murder of an ex-British army officer that they intervened. What was the name of the man shot dead by two I.R.A. members?

Answer: Field Marshall Henry Hughes Wilson

Field Marshall Sir Henry Hughes Wilson had been an important member of the British army during World War I, after which he made a brief foray into politics, eventually becoming an advisor to the Northern Irish government. He was fully against Irish independence and was very outspoken in his views. On the 22nd June 1922, he was gunned down in the street by two anti-treaty I.R.A. members (a number of policemen and bystanders were also shot as the men attempted to escape). Later, theories emerged that perhaps the order to kill him had in fact come from Michael Collins himself, but that seems unlikely, and certainly at the time, the British government assumed that the anti-treaty forces were responsible.

On a totally unrelated side note, fans of the TV series 'Dad's Army' might notice that the incorrect answers were the three highest ranking officers from the BBC show.
10. His hand forced by the threat of British intervention, Collins demanded that the anti-treaty garrison in Dublin surrender immediately. When they refused, he ordered the army to open fire, which they did, thereby starting the civil war. In which month of 1922 did these events transpire?

Answer: June

After the murder of Field Marshall Wilson, the British government made it clear to the leaders of the Irish Free State that they considered the anti-treaty forces to be a danger to the British Empire, and that if the Irish would not take action, the British government would. This threat spurred Michael Collins to action, and on the 27th of June, he ordered the immediate surrender of the anti-treaty garrison occupying the Four Courts. When they refused, he gave the order to open fire, and so the Irish Civil War started.

The Civil War was a defining period of Irish history: relationships built up during the War of Independence were shredded, it divided the country politically and locally (there are many records of family members fighting on opposite sides of the war) and atrocities were committed by both sides. However, in the end, the government had the support of the people and superior firepower (which the British government provided them with) and their victory was inevitable. However, the Civil War is still a sensitive subject today, and remains a divisive factor in Irish politics.

Thank you for taking my quiz, I hope you found it informative and that you enjoyed taking it as much as I enjoyed writing it. Don't forget to rate before you go! Thanks. : )
Source: Author yavemiel

This quiz was reviewed by FunTrivia editor bloomsby before going online.
Any errors found in FunTrivia content are routinely corrected through our feedback system.
3/28/2024, Copyright 2024 FunTrivia, Inc. - Report an Error / Contact Us