I don't think Charlie is dead...I have come to the conclusion that I am not going to assume anyone is dead until i either see them take their final breath or are buried (and don't open their eyes)...cuz there is still the possibility that Paulo and Nikki escaped but no one has seen them yet. ya never know! lol And plus I really don't want Charlie to be dead he is one of my favorites and he and Claire need to get together and have a "normal" life once they get off the Island.
_________________________
"I want to live, I want to experience the universe, and I want to eat pie!"
~Urgo (Stargate SG-1)