I agree to everything said here. He was simply fantastic in "Primal Fear", pretty scary in "American History X", and cute and funny in "Keeping the Faith". I still haven't seen "Fight Club", but I'm very confident that he's just as great as he always is. He didn't win an Oscar yet, did he? Though I seem to remember he's been nominated several times. I would've given him the trophy right away for his work in "Primal Fear"!!!
_________________________
If at first you don't succeed, hide all evidence that you tried