If I may weigh in...

I have seen both "There Will Be Blood" and "No Country for Old Men" (the latter mainly because of your trivia round awhile back, Gats

), and I thought both movies were incredibly good.
I can't say which deserves to win the Oscar - they were both amazing. However, overall I preferred "There Will Be Blood." Daniel Day-Lewis is an exceptional actor, and I was pleasantly surprised at how well Paul Dano rose to the challenge. While both movies showcased fantastic actors and a gripping story, "There Will Be Blood" haunted me for days after seeing it. I in no way mean to belittle “No Country for Old Men” either, because it is a powerful movie that is easily one of the best I have seen in a
long time. In fact, I will probably buy a copy of “No Country” to re-watch. (And it’s unlikely that I’ll do the same for “There Will Be Blood.”)
I agree wholeheartedly with your appraisal of the movie, John, and I wish you the best of luck with your auditions!