Rules
Terms of Use

Topic Options
#472529 - Sat May 23 2009 07:59 AM British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
There has been much in the media in the past week or so about the abuses of the expense system by Members of Parliament in the UK. They have been milking the system and bending the rules in some cases claiming for everything from hiring porn dvds to houses for ducks. You have had two people claiming for the same thing, you have one claiming for mortgage interest when he no longer has a mortgage. The list is quite amazing of what has been happening. Some are paying back amounts claimed. The whole thing stinks.

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/8064868.stm
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472530 - Sat May 23 2009 08:04 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
This lists some of the claims, everything from eyeliner pencils to dog bowls.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/newstopi...day-by-day.html
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472531 - Sun May 24 2009 10:54 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
Mugaboo Offline
Prolific

Registered: Fri Aug 13 2004
Posts: 1033
Loc: Scotland UK
The whole system was wrong from the start, and it should never have been set up like this in the first place.

Please remember that the British divorce courts have regarded this allowance as part of their income, regardless of whether it was claimed or not. Is it surprising that MPs are claiming it? One could argue that anyone who isn't, wouldn't make a very good Chancellor of the exchequer (or though not perhaps a popular one).

To my mind no "honourable" member would have claimed for these silly things. In many ways, showing us who's in politics for the money, and who's in to change Britain.

Top
#472532 - Wed Jun 03 2009 03:29 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
jonnowales Offline
Prolific

Registered: Mon Oct 30 2006
Posts: 1529
Loc: Swansea
Wales UK
Oh wow, what an effect this is having on the government at the moment. It is quite extraordinary!

Jacqui Smith has declared she will stand down from the cabinet and now, just two hours before what is going to be a car crash version of PMQs, Hazel Blears has announced her resignation from the cabinet.

Just crazy!

Top
#472533 - Wed Jun 03 2009 05:21 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
Professer Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: Mon May 19 2008
Posts: 464
Loc: Lincoln<br>England UK      ...
This was set up by Margaret Thatcher in the 1980's as she did not want to face a upsrising from the British People, at a time she was bashing the miners the sick and disabled and elderly. The Mp's of the time were looking for a substanial pay rise and she refused to endorse this. The expenses system was created and i am sure Mp's were told to fill there boots. And that they could make more from expenses then the pay rise they sought.
_________________________
Would I do it again? of course i would darling. Freddie Mercury

Top
#472534 - Sun Jun 07 2009 02:13 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
c0ntessa Offline
Participant

Registered: Sun May 17 2009
Posts: 8
Loc: Alberta Canada
What has been going on in your government, to me, seems to be a new world attitude. More for me, however I can get it; it's more mine than yours; everyone's doing it so how can it be wrong; don't get in my way for more with your moraltities.

Top
#472535 - Sun Jun 07 2009 02:14 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
c0ntessa Offline
Participant

Registered: Sun May 17 2009
Posts: 8
Loc: Alberta Canada
er... sorry for the bad typos etc.

Top
#472536 - Sun Jun 07 2009 03:24 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
Quote:

What has been going on in your government, to me, seems to be a new world attitude. More for me, however I can get it; it's more mine than yours; everyone's doing it so how can it be wrong; don't get in my way for more with your moraltities.




Sorry but I don't understand what you are trying to say. are you condoning their behaviour?
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472537 - Sun Jun 07 2009 04:01 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
Jabberwok Offline
Enthusiast

Registered: Tue Jun 24 2008
Posts: 427
Loc: Sussex England UK             
I don't get the impression that COntessa is approving of the behaviour, more lamenting the fact that the mantra of
'Greed is Good, Greed works'
has jumped across the pond and embedded itself in British politics.
Sadly COntessa, as the prof will probably tell you, greed amongst the ruling classes has always been dear to their hearts.
My copy of 1066 And All That is out on loan at the moment, but someone will be able to quote their explanation for the Magna Carta more accurately.
Something along the lines of
' Judgement of the Barons by a group of their peers who would understand them.'
_________________________
'The United Kingdom. Slightly smaller than Oregon'
CIA World Factbook

Top
#472538 - Sun Jun 07 2009 07:16 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
flopsymopsy Online   content

Administrator

Registered: Sat May 17 2008
Posts: 5470
Loc: Northampton England UK
Ah yes, the memorable History of England - defined as the bits you can remember. Everyone should read that book, except maybe Americans because when they became top dog History came to a .

(Don't hate me, read the book!)

Now then, the Magna Charter said...

    1. That no one was to be put to death, save for some reason (except the Common People).
    2. That everyone should be free (except the Common People).
    3. That everything should be of the same weight and measure throughout the Realm (except the Common People).
    4. That the Courts should be stationary, instead of following a very tiresome medieval official known as the King's Person all over the country.
    5. That no person should be fined to his utter ruin (except the King's Person).
    6. That the Barons should not be tried except by a special jury of other Barons who would understand.

    Magna Charter was therefore the chief cause of Democracy in England, and thus a very Good Thing for everyone (except the Common People).

Nothing's changed there then, lol.
_________________________
The Hubble Telescope has just picked up a sound from a fraction of a second before the Big Bang. The sound was "Uh oh".

Top
#472539 - Mon Jun 08 2009 12:56 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
picqero Offline
Multiloquent

Registered: Tue Dec 28 2004
Posts: 2813
Loc: Hertfordshire<br>England UK
One day a florist goes to a barber for a haircut.
After the haircut he asked about his bill and the barber replies "I can't accept money from you, I'm doing community service this week."
The florist was pleased and left the shop.
When the barber goes to open his shop next morning there is a 'thank you' card and a dozen roses waiting for him at the door.
Later, a baker comes in for a haircut, and when he tries to pay his bill, the barber again replies "I can't accept money from you, I'm doing community service this week." The baker is very happy and leaves the shop.
Next morning when the barber goes to open up, there is a 'thank you' card and a dozen donuts waiting for him at the door.
Later that day, a teacher comes in for a haircut, and when he tries to pay his bill, the barber again replies "I can't accept money from you, I'm doing community service this week."
The teacher is very happy and leaves the shop.
Next morning when the barber opens his shop, waiting for him there is a 'thank you' card and a dozen books, with titles such as 'How to Improve Your Business' and 'Becoming More Successful.'
Then, a Member of Parliament comes in for a haircut, and when he goes to pay his bill the barber again replies,
"I cannot accept money from you, I'm doing community service this week."
The Member of Parliament is very happy and leaves the shop.
Next morning when the barber goes to open up, there are a dozen Members of Parliament lined up waiting for a free haircut.
And that, my friends, illustrates the fundamental difference between the citizens of our country and our Members of Parliament!

That anecdote was of course 'tongue in cheek', and most MP's are both honest and open in their expense claims. My own MP Charles Walker publishes his salary and expenses on his website, and all his expenses are perfectly legitimate. He is also pro-active and hard working, both locally and within parliament, and frequently speaks in parliamentary debates.

Top
#472540 - Mon Jun 08 2009 03:58 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
dippo Offline
Mainstay

Registered: Sat Jun 14 2008
Posts: 745
Loc: London
England UK         
Why does your MP, whose constituency adjoins the M25, need to claim £10,000 for mortgage payments on a London property? I would have thought that his constituents, in a similar position, would commute.

Top
#472541 - Mon Jun 08 2009 04:04 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
Quote:

Why does your MP, whose constituency adjoins the M25, need to claim £10,000 for mortgage payments on a London property? I would have thought that his constituents, in a similar position, would commute.




Don't they normally have a place which is within so many minutes from the Houses of Parliament so they can go and vote, or did I just dream that?
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472542 - Mon Jun 08 2009 04:13 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472543 - Mon Jun 08 2009 05:46 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
dippo Offline
Mainstay

Registered: Sat Jun 14 2008
Posts: 745
Loc: London
England UK         
That was probably a lot more relevant when the House sat all evening and into the night. That was also the argument for London MPs to have second homes 'within the sound of the division bell'.

The hours of the House of Commons have now been amended, and they no longer sit into the evening or late at night, so if an MP is not in the chamber at the time of a vote, the most logical place for him to be would be in his office.

Top
#472544 - Mon Jun 08 2009 06:09 AM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
sue943 Offline
Administrator

Registered: Sun Dec 19 1999
Posts: 38005
Loc: Jersey
Channel Islands    
Or perhaps her office.
_________________________
Many a child has been spoiled because you can't spank a Grandma!

Top
#472545 - Thu Jun 18 2009 04:26 PM Re: British MPs expenses scandal
picqero Offline
Multiloquent

Registered: Tue Dec 28 2004
Posts: 2813
Loc: Hertfordshire<br>England UK
Quote:

Why does your MP, whose constituency adjoins the M25, need to claim £10,000 for mortgage payments on a London property? I would have thought that his constituents, in a similar position, would commute.



Apologies for not responding sooner, but my life is pretty hectic at present
I've no problem with my MP claiming part of the agreed second home allowance. His constituency, as you correctly say, "borders the M25", which means he'd spend three to four hours per day traveling to and from Westminster. Much of this journey would be in overcrowded trains, making it impossible for him to work while traveling, so if there's a system in place to make his work time more effective, then I'm all for it provided it's not abused. What his constituents do or don't do is totally irrelevant; some will be better off and some worse off. Most MPs' constituents don't get secretarial allowances either, but that doesn't mean MPs shouldn't get them. The £10K claimed by my MP last year was not just mortgage payment, but was the total cost of his London accomodation, including mortgage, council tax, utilities, subsistence, maintenance and removal costs, and frankly you don't get much for £10K in central London!
My MP's expenses are in the lowest bracket of all MPs' expense claims, and as such are reasonable for someone in his position.
It is not a question of 'how much', but more of 'how justifiable', and the expense claims of some MPs, including most senior ministers are simply appalling.
'Flipping' homes is one of the most common practices, one incidently which my own MP doesn't do, and an extremely profitable one for those who do it, and the Chancellor has done it four times at least! This means nominating which home is your primary home, so that expenses can then be claimed on the second home. The game is to then get expensive work done, anything from digging out moats, landscaping gardens, building extensions, etc, etc, on the secondary home for which the costs can be claimed as expenses. The home is then flipped so the secondary home becomes the primary home, and the expensive 'expenses' work then starts on the 'new' second home. One cabinet minister claimed the spare room in her sister's London house was her primary home, and the large house just outside London which she owned, and at which her husband and children lived, was her 'second home' thus eligible for huge expense claims.
There are many such cases, some far worse and possibly criminal, so I'm very happy to have an honest MP.


Edited by picqero (Thu Jun 18 2009 04:32 PM)

Top

Moderator:  ladymacb29, sue943