FREE! Click here to Join FunTrivia. Thousands of games, quizzes, and lots more!
MLB Players Odd One Out Quizzes, Trivia and Puzzles
MLB Players Odd One Out Quizzes, Trivia

MLB Players Odd One Out Trivia

MLB Players Odd One Out Trivia Quizzes

  1. Home
  2. »
  3. Quizzes
  4. »
  5. Sports Trivia
  6. »
  7. MLB Players

Fun Trivia
26 quizzes and 260 trivia questions.
1.
  Who Doesn't Belong? [1] editor best quiz   popular trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
See if you can answer the following questions about Major League Baseball players.
Difficult, 10 Qns, ralzzz, Dec 08 09
Difficult
ralzzz gold member
8231 plays
2.
  Baseball's Missing Links editor best quiz   best quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
You find the missing link between two players, one player that played with the other two greats. I hope that you have fun with it! :-)
Average, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Jun 23 09
Average
Nightmare gold member
2842 plays
3.
Dont Accuse Me
  Don't Accuse Me!    
Photo Quiz
 10 Qns
Three did it, one did not. You select the odd one out in all multiple choice questions along with some pictures that probably won't help. Have fun with it! :)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Nov 26 18
Tough
Nightmare gold member
Nov 26 18
987 plays
4.
Baseballs Chain Gang
  Baseball's Chain Gang    
Photo Quiz
 10 Qns
I'll give you two great players and you name the only player that links the two together in all multiple choice. The pictures might help or might not. Good luck. :)
Difficult, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Sep 01 11
Difficult
Nightmare gold member
1170 plays
5.
  Put Out the Match!    
Match Quiz
 10 Qns
The statement matches three players and one player does not belong. Select the player and put them out! This is going to be a thinker.
Very Easy, 10 Qns, dg_dave, Oct 26 16
Very Easy
dg_dave gold member
454 plays
6.
  I Had the Honor!   best quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
In all multiple choice, you find the player to have had the honor of playing with the two Major League greats listed. I hope that you have fun with it! :-)
Average, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Apr 15 07
Average
Nightmare gold member
897 plays
7.
  Baseball Connections!   best quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
All multiple choice for you to find the person that links the other two greats together. I hope that you have fun with it! :-)
Average, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Aug 07 08
Average
Nightmare gold member
835 plays
8.
  Cobb, Mantle, Mays, or Killebrew?   best quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Short and sweet as you select the player that the statement applies to. This might be a little tricky. :)
Average, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Jan 19 10
Average
Nightmare gold member
506 plays
9.
  I Am "Excepted"   top quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Of the four well known players listed for each question, all will have achieved the milestone mentioned except for one. You pick the player that doesn't belong. Good luck.
Tough, 10 Qns, fredsixties, Oct 26 10
Tough
fredsixties
743 plays
10.
  Odd Man Out   great trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
In all multiple choice, you pick the player who doesn't belong. Have fun! :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Jan 22 07
Tough
Nightmare gold member
1163 plays
trivia question Quick Question
Three of these pitching greats won at least 25 games in a season at least three times in their careers. Which one did not do it even once?

From Quiz "Honest, I Didn't Do It"




11.
  Who Doesn't Belong?   top quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
All multiple choice about some feats that players accomplished. You pick the one that didn't do it. I hope that you enjoy it! :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Sep 25 07
Tough
Nightmare gold member
978 plays
12.
  Honest, I Didn't Do It   top quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
All multiple choice for you to identify who the odd man out is. I hope that you enjoy it! :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Jan 16 08
Tough
Nightmare gold member
830 plays
13.
  Waylon, Willie, and Hank?   great trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Not a country music quiz, but an all multiple choice quiz about two of the greatest players ever in baseball. Was it Willie Mays or Hank Aaron? I hope that you enjoy it. :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Dec 07 06
Tough
Nightmare gold member
729 plays
14.
  Let's Hold Hands   great trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
All multiple choice about one player who played with two Major League greats. I hope you have fun with it. :)
Average, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Dec 23 09
Average
Nightmare gold member
382 plays
15.
  Who Doesn't Belong? [2]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Can you identify which player does not belong with their peers? This tough quiz should really test your knowledge on baseball history.
Tough, 10 Qns, ralzzz, Dec 08 09
Tough
ralzzz gold member
1065 plays
16.
  Odd One Out    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
See if you can pick who does not belong in this all multiple choice quiz. I hope that you enjoy it. :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, nightmare, Jul 21 07
Tough
nightmare gold member
777 plays
17.
  Not the Right Way to Bat?    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
All multiple choice as always. Each question lists three right-handed batters and one left-hander. You pick out the one who never batted the 'right' way. Thanks for playing. :-)
Average, 10 Qns, nightmare, Jul 10 08
Average
nightmare gold member
547 plays
18.
  Major Missing Links   popular trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
In all multiple choice, you find the only player who played with the two greats listed. This might be a challenge. :-)
Difficult, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Jan 24 09
Difficult
Nightmare gold member
391 plays
19.
  The Odd Man Out [2]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
My second quiz on who is the odd man out.
Average, 10 Qns, royals794, Dec 07 09
Average
royals794
583 plays
20.
  Who Doesn't Belong? [4]   popular trivia quiz  
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Can you pick which player does not belong with his peers? Each question will describe a milestone or feat, that only three players will have accomplished. All you have to do is indicate which player does not belong.
Difficult, 10 Qns, ralzzz, Nov 09 07
Difficult
ralzzz gold member
1024 plays
21.
  What an Honor!    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
A pretty tough quiz to find just one player, a missing link who played with both baseball greats listed. Good luck. :-)
Tough, 10 Qns, Nightmare, Nov 09 07
Tough
Nightmare gold member
337 plays
22.
  Who Doesn't Belong? [3]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Pick the one baseball player that does not fit with the other players for the statistic listed.
Difficult, 10 Qns, ralzzz, Sep 01 11
Difficult
ralzzz gold member
615 plays
23.
  Gwynn, Ripken, Both, or Neither?    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Gwynn and Ripken were two of the greatest and grittiest baseball players of the 1980s and 1990s. I'll name an accomplishment and you have to tell me whether it describes Gwynn, Ripken, Both, or Neither!
Difficult, 10 Qns, bsd987, Sep 01 11
Difficult
bsd987
433 plays
24.
  Odd Man Out [1]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Three of the four players fit into a category. You pick the one who is the odd man out.
Very Difficult, 10 Qns, dog92794, Dec 07 09
Very Difficult
dog92794
497 plays
25.
  Odd Man Out [2]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
This quiz is my second installation of odd man out. Again, three of the players fit into the category I give you. You pick the one who doesn't, the odd man out.
Difficult, 10 Qns, dog92794, Dec 07 09
Difficult
dog92794
337 plays
26.
  The Odd Man Out: [1]    
Multiple Choice
 10 Qns
Which player does not fit amongst the answer choices?
Difficult, 10 Qns, royals794, Dec 07 09
Difficult
royals794
449 plays

MLB Players Odd One Out Trivia Questions
1. All the players listed here achieved the milestone of hitting at least 50 home runs in one Major League season except for which one?

From Quiz I Am "Excepted"

Answer: Henry Aaron

Henry Aaron did hit 755 home runs during his Major League career, but his high in one season was only 47 occurring in the 1971 season affirming his consistency. Aaron hit 30 or more home runs 15 times during his 23-year career. Willie Mays hit a career high 52 home runs in 1965, and Cecil Fielder stroked 51 home runs in 1990. Brady Anderson hit 50 home runs in 1996 after never hitting more than 21 in a season.

2. Which player hit 573 career home runs in their career, while never hitting 50 in a season?

From Quiz Cobb, Mantle, Mays, or Killebrew?

Answer: Harmon Killebrew

Killebrew played for the Senators/Twins in 22 seasons. His season high was 49 twice, in 1964 and 1969.

3. Which Hall of Famer played with the great Ernie Banks and slugger Roger Maris on different teams?

From Quiz Let's Hold Hands

Answer: Lou Brock

Before becoming a household base stealing name with the Cardinals, Brock was a rookie with the Chicago Cubs in 1961 where he met Mr. Cub. In 1961, Maris was busy breaking Babe Ruth's season home run record with the Yankees. Lou found Roger Maris on the Cardinals' 1968 roster. Brock broke Maury Will's season stolen base record when he stole 118 in 1974. Rickey Henderson later broke Brock's record. The others were all retired before Maris was a rookie in 1957.

4. 1978 Pittsburgh Pirate Dave Parker won the NL MVP. In 2008, Cardinal Albert Pujols also won the NL MVP. Who was the only player to play with both these greats?

From Quiz Major Missing Links

Answer: Chuck Finley

Finley was a pitcher whose career spanned from 1986-2002. He played 15 of his 17 seasons with the Angels. 12 times he won in double-figures and had consecutive 18-9 seasons in 1990 and 1991. Parker and Finley teamed up with the Angels in 1991. Finley and Pujols made the connection with the Cardinals in 2002.

5. Pete Rose won the NL Rookie of the Year with Cincinnati in 1963. The Reds' Scott Williamson won the Rookie of the Year in 1999. Who was the only player in Major League baseball to play with both on the Reds?

From Quiz Baseball's Missing Links

Answer: Barry Larkin

Larkin played with Rose on the 1986 Reds, then Williamson with the Reds in 2001. Barry was a career Red, playing from 1986-2004. He won three Gold Glove awards at shortstop. Larkin was the 1995 NL MVP over Dante Bichette of the Rockies, and Greg Maddux of the Braves.

6. Which player did not have a career batting average above .315?

From Quiz The Odd Man Out [2]

Answer: Jackie Robinson

Hall of Famer Jackie Robinson had a .311 career batting average in his ten-year career with the Brooklyn Dodgers and is most famous for breaking baseball's color barrier.

7. Which player did not record at least 3,000 hits and 500 home runs in his career?

From Quiz The Odd Man Out: [1]

Answer: Ted Williams

Williams connected for 521 home runs in his Hall of Fame career. He collected 2,654 hits.

8. Many players have hit a home run in their first Major League at-bat. Even more rare is to hit a home run on the very first pitch seen in the Major Leagues. Which player did not accomplish this?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [4]

Answer: Joe DiMaggio

On May 10, 1936, DiMaggio made his New York Yankee home debut, hitting a home run off the Philadelphia A's George Turbeville, but not on the first pitch thrown to him. Joe DiMaggio hit 29 home runs in his rookie season with the New York Yankees.

9. Which player did not hit a home run on the first pitch he saw in the major leagues?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [3]

Answer: Willie McCovey

The great Willie McCovey did not hit a home run in his first game at all, although he did go 4 for 4 with a couple of triples against the Phillies' great and Hall of Famer, Robin Roberts.

10. Which former Baltimore Oriole did not bat the right way?

From Quiz Not the Right Way to Bat?

Answer: Boog Powell

14 of his 17 seasons were played in an Oriole uniform. John Wesley "Boog" Powell, played from 1961-1977. The first baseman and also 1970 American League MVP, hit 303 home runs for Baltimore.

11. Which rookie did not hit 30 or more home runs?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [2]

Answer: Barry Bonds

Barry Bonds only hit 16 home runs in 113 games his rookie season (1987)with the Pittsburgh Pirates. His 16 homers in 413 at bats equals a 25.8 home run/at bat ratio. Not nearly as impressive as the 13.3 home run/at bat ratio he has for his career. Mark McGwire hit 49 homers in 1987, his rookie season for the Oakland A's. McGwire went on to hit 583 homers in his career, or a home run/at bat ratio of 10.8, with the A's and the St. Louis Cardinals. Frank Robinson hit 38 homers for the Cincinnati Reds in 1956, his rookie year. Robinson had a total of 586 home runs for a home run/at bat ratio of 17.1. Robinson played 22 years for the Reds, Baltimore Orioles, LA Dodgers, California Angels, and Cleveland Indians. His best home run production was in 1966, when he hit 49 homers for the Orioles. Tony Oliva hit 32 homers in 1964 for the Minnesota Twins. Oliva finished his 13 year career, all with the Twins, with 220 homers. That equals out to a ratio of 28.6 homers per at bats.

12. Which pitcher did not win 300 games?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [1]

Answer: Jim Kaat

Jim Kaat only won 283 in his great career. Kaat pitched 25 seasons, mostly with the Twins, and retired at the age of 44. He was 4th in the Cy Young voting in 1975 with the White Sox. Plank, playing most of his career with the Philadelphia Athletics, won 327 games. Wynn, who played with the Washington Senators, Cleveland Indians, and Chicago White Sox, won 300 games. Finally, Tim Keefe, whose best season included winning 42 games for the New York Giants in 1886, won 342 for his career.

13. All the following speedsters stole at least 100 bases in a single Major League season except for which pair of legs?

From Quiz I Am "Excepted"

Answer: Tim Raines

Tim Raines was one of the most prolific base stealers of the 1980s but never reached the 100 stolen base club. His high was 90 thefts in the 1983 season. Maury Wills was the first Major Leaguer to break the 100 stole base plateau when he swiped 104 bases in 1962. Vince Coleman stole over 100 bases three times including his rookie season of 1985 when he swiped 110. Lou Brock stole 118 of his career 938 stole bases in 1974. Of course, there is Rickey Henderson who compiled 130 steals during the 1982 season.

14. Hank Aaron of the Braves ruled the National League in the 1950s and 1960s. Tom Glavine ruled the mound for the Braves in the 1990s. Only two players in baseball history played with both. One was Darrell Evans, and who was the other?

From Quiz Baseball Connections!

Answer: Phil Niekro

The others weren't born until the 1960s. Phil played with Aaron on the 1965 Milwaukee Braves, then with Glavine on the 1987 Atlanta Braves. Phil was a 20-game winner three times and led the league in wins twice. Niekro retired with a 318-274 record at the age of 48. The hall inducted him in 1997. Evans spent 21 seasons with the Braves, Giants, and Tigers. He played with Aaron with the Braves in 1971, then Glavine with the Braves in 1989.

15. Although I cannot fault my friend, I believe I was the most consistent. Other than my rookie season, I batted at least .300 in every year of my major league career. Who am I?

From Quiz Gwynn, Ripken, Both, or Neither?

Answer: Tony Gwynn

This might be the most impressive of Gwynn's career achievements (1982-2001). He batted .289 as a rookie and that was his worst season.

16. One swing of the bat made this player go down in infamy. Who was it that was honored to have played with both Willie Mays and Hank Aaron?

From Quiz I Had the Honor!

Answer: Bobby Thomson

It was Thomson's "shot heard around the world" in the 1951 season that put the Giants on top of the Dodgers in the National League. Mays was a Giant rookie in 1951. The Giants traded Thomson to the Braves in 1954, but Thomson injured himself, and the Braves replaced him with rookie Hank Aaron. The rest was history.

17. Dodger Sandy Koufax and Yankee Whitey Ford battled it out in a World Series in 1963. Who is the only player that has played with both these pitching greats?

From Quiz What an Honor!

Answer: Gordie Windhorn

Windhorn played with Ford on the 1959 Yankees, and later played with Koufax on the 1961 Dodgers. Windhorn played for only three seasons, retiring in 1962.

18. Which slugger did not compile over 1500 RBIs during their career?

From Quiz The Odd Man Out [2]

Answer: Jose Canseco

Canseco drove in 1,407 runs during his career with the Oakland Athletics, Texas Rangers, Boston Red Sox, New York Yankees, and Toronto Blue Jays. He also cracked 462 home runs and had a career average of .266.

19. Which player did not compile at least 500 home runs in their career?

From Quiz The Odd Man Out: [1]

Answer: Willie Stargell

Stargell collected 475 home runs in his Hll of Fame career, tied with Stan Musial on the home run list.

20. Which player did not steal second, third, and home, in the same game?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [4]

Answer: Lou Brock

The speedy Lou Brock never accomplished this feat, although he did steal 938 bases in his 19 year career. Brock, a baseball Hall of Fame member, had his best year swiping bases in 1974, when he stole 118 bases. Of all players to steal second, third, and home, Ty Cobb had the most success. He accomplished that feat on six separate occasions. Ty Cobb also stole home more times than anyone else listed, with 54 successful steals.

21. Which player has never had three triples in one game?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [3]

Answer: Ozzie Smith

Ozzie Smith never had a game where he hit three triples. Ernie Banks did it for the Cubs in 1966. Shawn Dunston also did it as a member of the Cubs in 1990. Joe DiMaggio did it for the Yankees in 1938.

22. Which former Dodger/Giant does not belong with these right-handed hitters?

From Quiz Not the Right Way to Bat?

Answer: Brett Butler

Always the clutch hitter, Butler also played for the Braves, Indians, and Mets. Many of his left-handed hits were lead-off bunts. He retired in 1997 after 17 seasons.

23. Which rookie did not throw a no-hitter?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [2]

Answer: Tom Seaver

Although Hall of Famer Tom Seaver won 16 games and struck out 170 his rookie season as a New York Met, he did not throw a no-hitter until June 16, 1978 as a member of the Cincinnati Reds. He beat the St. Louis Cardinals 4-0 striking out 3 and walking 3. The opposing pitcher was John Denny. Seaver went on to play for the White Sox and Red Sox, before retiring in 1986 after 20 stellar season. Vida Blue threw his rookie no-hitter September 21, 1970, as a member of the Oakland A's. He beat the Minnesota Twins 6-0, striking out 9 and walking 1. The opposing pitcher was Jim Perry. Blue went on to play for the San Francisco Giants and the Kansas City Royals, winning 209 games in his 17 year career. Blue was a 6 time All Star and won the Cy Young and the MVP award in 1971. Wilson Alvarez got his rookie no-hitter on August 11, 1991, as a member of the Chicago White Sox. Alvarez beat Dave Johnson and the Baltimore Orioles 7-0, striking out 7 and walking 5. Besides the White Sox, Alvarez has played for the Giants and Tampa Bay Devil Rays. Wilson was an All Star in 1994. Burt Hooton got his rookie no-hitter April 16, 1972, as a member of the Chicago Cubs. He beat the Philadelphia Phillies 4-0, walking 1 and fanning 6. Steve Arlin was the opposing pitcher. Hooton went on to play 15 years with the Cubs, Dodgers and Texas Rangers posting a record of 151 wins and 136 losses. Hooton was an All Star in 1981, winning All Star MVP for the game.

24. What player has never completed an unassisted triple play (UTP)?

From Quiz Who Doesn't Belong? [1]

Answer: Bill Mazeroski

Although Bill Mazeroski never completed the UTP, he was a great second baseman who helped turn 161 double plays in 1966, while a member of the Pittsburgh Pirates. Ron Hansen completed the UTP in 1968, while a member of the Washington Senators. Rafael Furcal turned the UTP in 2003, as a member of the Atlanta Braves. Bill Wambsganss managed the UTP in 1920, when he played for the Indians.

25. Only one pitcher, and a Hall of Fame pitcher at that, pitched with both Sandy Koufax and Fernando Valenzuela in his career. Who was this 300-game winner?

From Quiz Let's Hold Hands

Answer: Don Sutton

Koufax retired as a Dodger in 1966. Valenzuela was a rookie with the Dodgers in 1980. Sutton was a Dodger from 1966-1980 before being traded to Houston in 1981. Don retired as a Dodger in 1988, back again with Fernando, with a 324-256 record. Cooperstown inducted Sutton in 1998.

26. Phillies great Mike Schmidt won the NL MVP in 1980. Phillies Jimmy Rollins won another MVP for the team in 2007. Which pitcher was the only player to share a roster with both, and in both instances with the Phillies?

From Quiz Major Missing Links

Answer: Dennis Cook

Cook was paired with Schmidt and the Phillies in 1989, then with Rollins with the Phillies in 2001. Dennis was a pitcher of 18 seasons that began in San Francisco in 1988. He retired as an Angel in 2002 with career marks of 64-46, 9 saves, and 739 strikeouts over 15 seasons.

27. Three of the four have 500 career stolen bases. Who is the odd man out?

From Quiz Odd Man Out [2]

Answer: Roberto Alomar

Roberto Alomar only had 474 career steals. Joe Morgan had 689 career steals. Barry Bonds had 514 career steals. Paul Molitor had 504 career steals.

28. Although I wasn't known particularly for my speed, I did hit 10 triples in a season at one point in my career. Who am I?

From Quiz Gwynn, Ripken, Both, or Neither?

Answer: Tony Gwynn

Gwynn did it four times. Ripken's career high was 7 trples in a season.

29. Dodger Maury Wills broke Ty Cobb's season stolen base record in 1962 with 104. Oakland's Rickey Henderson later set a new season record in 1982 with 130. Who was the only player, and a speedster himself, to play with both these thieves?

From Quiz Baseball's Missing Links

Answer: Davey Lopes

The others never stole more than 18 bases in a season. Davey played with Wills on the 1973 Dodgers in his official rookie season, and most of his career with the Dodgers. Davey was also there alongside Rickey with the Athletics in 1982, when Henderson stole 130. Lopes stole 557 bases of his own during his career.

30. Two very short people in baseball were Eddie Gaedel who had only one plate appearance in 1951 with the St. Louis Browns, and an Angels' outfielder Albie Pearson. Which player shared the uniform of both?

From Quiz What an Honor!

Answer: Ned Garver

Ned Garver played with Eddie Gaedel on the 1951 St. Louis Browns, then with Albie Pearson for the Los Angeles Angels in 1961. Garver pitched for the Browns, Tigers, Athletics, and then retired as an Angel in 1961.

This is category 20688
play trivia = Top 5% Rated Quiz, take trivia quiz Top 10% Rated Quiz, test trivia quiz Top 20% Rated Quiz, popular trivia A Well Rated Quiz
new quizzes = added recently, editor pick = Editor's Pick editor = FunTrivia Editor gold = Gold Member

Teachers / educators: FunTrivia welcomes the use of our website and quizzes in the classroom as a teaching aid or for preparing and testing students. See our education section. Our quizzes are printable and may be used as question sheets by k-12 teachers, parents, and home schoolers.

 ·  All questions, answers, and quiz content on this website is copyright FunTrivia, Inc and may not be reproduced without permission. Any images from TV shows and movies are copyright their studios, and are being used under "fair use" for commentary and education.