| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (First Death; before events on the island) | William Blore |
| 2. (First one on the island) | Thomas Rogers |
| 3. | Isaac Morris |
| 4. | Justice Wargrave |
| 5. | Anthony Marston |
| 6. | Philip Lombard |
| 7. | Vera Claythorne |
| 8. | Emily Brent |
| 9. | General MacArthur |
| 10. | Ethel Rogers |
| 11. (Final Death) | Dr. Armstrong |