| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (House allocations) | T M Riddle's diary |
| 2. (Wood talks Quidditch) | Prophecy Orb |
| 3. (Moaning Myrtle) | The Sorting Hat |
| 4. (Basilisk) | The Time-Turner |
| 5. (Hogsmeade visits) | The Resurrection Stone |
| 6. (Saving Buckbeak) | Marauder's Map |
| 7. (The second task) | The Golden Snitch |
| 8. (Attempted rescue of Sirius) | Gillyweed |
| 9. (Slughorn's lessons) | Half-blood Prince's potions book |
| 10. (Battle of Hogwarts) | The Sword of Gryffindor |