| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (688) | Albert Pujols |
| 2. (316) | Vladimir Guerrero |
| 3. (298) | Stan Musial |
| 4. (293) | Barry Bonds |
| 5. (250) | Hank Aaron |
| 6. (246) | Ken Griffey, Jr. |
| 7. (180) | Joey Votto |
| 8. (147) | Cal Ripken, Jr. |
| 9. (107) | Paul Molitor |
| 10. (100) | Wade Boggs |