| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (696) | Reggie Jackson |
| 2. (660) | Gary Sheffield |
| 3. (612) | David Ortiz |
| 4. (609) | Mike Schmidt |
| 5. (573) | Jim Thome |
| 6. (563) | Harmon Killebrew |
| 7. (548) | Willie Mays |
| 8. (541) | Alex Rodriguez |
| 9. (521) | Sammy Sosa |
| 10. (509) | Frank Thomas |