| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (def. LA Galaxy : 1996) | San Jose Earthquakes |
| 2. (def. Colorado Rapids :1997) | San Jose Earthquakes |
| 3. (def. D.C. United : 1998) | LA Galaxy |
| 4. (def. LA Galaxy :1999) | D.C. United |
| 5. (def. Chicago Fire FC : 2000) | Kansas City Wizards |
| 6. (def. LA Galaxy : 2001) | D.C. United |
| 7. (def. New England Revolution : 2002) | D.C. United |
| 8. (def. Chicago Fire FC : 2003) | D.C. United |
| 9. (def. Kansas City Wizards :2004) | LA Galaxy |
| 10. (def. New England Revolution : 2005) | Chicago Fire FC |