Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 1 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
TheAtwood4155
|
I say it was madness when Snape had killed Dumbledore, but Mad-Eye's death was all the more tragic.....i mean he was an experianced Auror so, he would've stood a chance against Voldemort if he really would've wanted to.....but since Mundungus moved out of the way, Mad-Eye had to take the killing curse straight in the face or w/e..... Reply #1. Mar 15 08, 11:06 PM |
nokeweb
|
Dobby was a sad death Reply #2. Apr 21 08, 6:32 PM |
trivfan
|
I have to agree with you GriifinLover. Fred's death was so tragic. Of course so was Tonks and Remus, but at least one didn't have to live without the other, small consolation as that is to their son. Moody's death while sad, at least he went down fighting. Reply #3. Apr 21 08, 7:48 PM |
LOTRluver
|
i have to agree with nokeweb, dobby's death was the saddest Reply #4. Apr 29 08, 5:26 PM |
sgrx1030
|
The death that got me had to be Fred Weasley. I have an identical twin sister and we related so much to Fred and George. So seeing one die was very sad for me. Dobby was sad too. Reply #5. May 01 08, 2:28 PM |
toocool4u
|
Fred was definitly the saddest possibly because he was always so cheerful, as was Dobby. Reply #6. May 06 08, 3:28 PM |
andromaster
|
Lupin and Tonks death was pretty sad too. They never got to see their son, Teddy, grow up. Reply #7. May 08 08, 3:00 PM |
MeganRead 
|
Oh, my poor, poor Dobby and Fred! Joanne went too far then and I doubt I'll ever have the courage to read that chapter again. Fred was such a major character, and Dobby...oh Dobby. Reply #8. May 20 08, 12:59 PM |
rayven80
|
Sirius I think was the saddest. He just fell and never came back. Reply #9. May 21 08, 1:35 PM |
| hp_fan10
|
Snape's death was the worse.. He should have lived... Reply #10. May 24 08, 8:45 AM |
| backhandgal
|
I think Fred's death was really sad because he Joe points out that he died laughing. Now to me, that makes ot even sadder. And Lupin and Tonks- they never got to see Teddy grow up. Reply #11. May 26 08, 7:36 PM |
dj168
|
I'm sad Dumbledore died. Reply #12. May 26 08, 7:56 PM |
| anetabug
|
freds death seems the worse to me i have a twin bro and being twins you are close you have your own language sometimes can tell what the other is thinking and i almost lost my bro a few months back it would be really hard to get over it not having that connection and finishing each others sentences you would just wait to hear it and with fred and george they were identical playing games and they were supposed to be closer than me and my bro -we fight ALL the time -they worked together and everything we could never do that so to lose a twin like that would be hard Reply #13. May 27 08, 2:28 PM |
arwenevenstar1
|
At first I couldn't get over the fact she killed Dumbledore off, but then in the next book she killed Fred Weasley I couldn't believe it, I can just picture poor George pining away for his brother they were a team and best friends it's just so sad. I also think poor little Hedwig dying was very sad. Oh, for crying out loud I think they were all sad! I'm so depressed....... Reply #14. May 28 08, 3:36 PM |
| amyrn007
|
Dumbledore's death really hit me hard. I remember crying when I was reading the book! But when Dobby died, that was way too much for me! Poor Dobby Reply #15. Jun 07 08, 8:20 PM |
vampiregirl8
|
I cried for days when Fred was killed, and I almost went into depression when Sirius was killed. Reply #16. Jun 08 08, 10:26 PM |
| amyrn007
|
yeah know what vampiregirl.....now that you mention it, Sirius's death was a blow...You just pictured HP living with him and having a better life, huh?...then it was gone. Reply #17. Jun 10 08, 6:40 AM |
knud77
|
I think Voldemort's death was the saddest because now there are no more books to look forward to. Reply #18. Jun 10 08, 7:05 AM |
| amyrn007
|
maybe he is not really dead? hmmmmmm Reply #19. Jun 10 08, 8:01 AM |
Chrisy018
|
I think Snapes death was bad. Here the whole time everyone hated him and wanted him and and when he is finally gone we find out he really was a great man. Reply #20. Jun 17 08, 6:40 PM |
149 replies. On page 1 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: