Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 2 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
aligirl100
|
I think that it was really bad to kill off Snape. I mean in the end, at least to me, he really was a good guy. Either that or the death of Hedwig. Now that was tragic. Or possibly Dobby's death! In the end, most of them were realyl bad for me. Reply #21. Jun 23 08, 1:35 PM |
Toadpaw
|
They were all sad, but I have to say, the one that was worst for me was probably Voldemort. This makes no more books for us to read! Unless... Reply #22. Jun 26 08, 7:48 PM |
pagea 
|
The saddest deaths for me were Hedwig and Dobby, becase they were just out of the blue and you didn't really see it coming. Reply #23. Jun 27 08, 1:46 AM |
| t0mb0y_16
|
Albus Dumbledore's death in the sixth book, It was extremely heart-rending. He was my most favorite character in the whole series. Reply #24. Jun 27 08, 2:16 PM |
renochamp2006
|
i think fred,dumbeldore and dobby made me sad Reply #25. Jun 28 08, 2:58 PM |
| molly1351
|
I think Fred's death was very sad because whats Fred and George without Fred! Also i fell sorry for Snape because he was a good guy in the end. Dobby and Hedwig were also sad because they were friends with Harry even though Hedwig couldnt talk! Reply #26. Jul 01 08, 1:36 PM |
JaneMarple
|
Sirius's death was very sad for me. He was just beginning to learn how to live again, and found Harry. Dumbledore's did not affect me as much, as Dumbledore was old. But the most emotional death for me was Dobby. The way Harry dug his grave with no magic :( Also Fred's death was painful for all the Weasley family, especailly George. Reply #27. Jul 02 08, 1:57 PM |
| NMkHAN
|
I also think sirius black's death was very unfair i literally cried after reading harry hadrly got some one to love him like his parents but he also died Reply #28. Jul 20 08, 8:04 AM |
| xPaige
|
Sirius, Remus, Tonks, Hedwig, Dobby ... they were all sad! It's strange 'cause I hardly ever cry while reading, and the only time I cried when reading the series was when Dobby died... Reply #29. Jul 28 08, 7:42 AM |
| lioness37
|
A lot of them. Sirius, because Harry finally had a sort of parental figure that he loved, and then...it was just such a sudden and awful death. Dumbledore, because he was Harry's mentor and really wise and just awesome. And, when you read it, it was as if Dumbledore had been betrayed by somebody that he trusted so much. Also Dobby. That was just awful. Reply #30. Jul 30 08, 10:47 AM |
Rachel xx
|
^^ I agree totally. Those were the actual ones I was going to say :) Reply #31. Aug 02 08, 1:53 PM |
TaraSloan
|
Dumbledore, Dobby and when they brought all the bodies into the great hall and Harry saw Lupin, Tonks and Fred all made me cry! Reply #32. Aug 07 08, 7:30 AM |
| TaraSloan
|
and all the Sirius death scene and Dumbledore talking to Harry afterwords. I couldn't stop crying! Reply #33. Aug 07 08, 7:31 AM |
Ilona_Ritter
|
I cried when Dumbledore was killed. I was so mad at Snape to and then I was so glad to find out he really was good becuase he's my favorite character so of course I cried when he died as well. Reply #34. Aug 17 08, 11:41 PM |
| poshprice
|
Hedwig and Dobby - that was so mean I actually cried. Plus the shock of it. Reply #35. Aug 28 08, 5:53 PM |
Buddy1
|
The worst death was that of Dumbledore. That was as close to crying as I came while reading the Harry Potter books. However, unlike many other fans, I accepted his death rather than come up with ways he might have survived. Reply #36. Aug 28 08, 9:26 PM |
slytherinwitch
|
Dumbledore got a portrait immediately after his death, a huge huge funeral (interestingly, the only one to get such treatment) and appears later to confirm he is really dead. Seeing plotholes in the text and questioning what really happened when it isn't spelled out so nicely is a prerogative of the reader. Some writers deliberately leave things open-ended for readers to interpret themselves. Some writers have exploited loopholes in their own stories to change their minds about writing certain characters again after attempts to kill them off in earlier stories. If it isn't set in stone, it's not final. It's open-ended and one interpretation is as valid as any other. Reply #37. Aug 28 08, 9:46 PM |
| RoboRokr
|
my thinker rinker thinks that Dobby was not the not the worse death Reply #38. Sep 04 08, 5:28 AM |
| kurauzumaki01
|
The Worst dead was Fred's, I didn´t see that coming and I cried so much when I red that part, he died making jokes, percy an george not willing to get appart from him! besides he's one of my fav characters and there will never be somene like him... He was a truly inspiration for me! It breaks my heart to think about it! Reply #39. Sep 06 08, 11:12 AM |
macabrescribe
|
I was sad when Moody died. He was my favorite character of the series. Reply #40. Sep 06 08, 11:21 AM |
149 replies. On page 2 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: