Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 4 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
DotSnoopyFan 
|
Dobby's death caught me off guard and Fred's death was sad too. Reply #61. Jan 25 09, 9:21 PM |
Tondalay-o
|
i think either Hedwig, Dobby (i cried) or Fred (i cried) Reply #62. Feb 01 09, 4:10 PM |
Ardicrocks
|
I hated it when Dobby died. Reply #63. Feb 12 09, 11:59 AM |
NCW75
|
I'd say Hedwig, Dobby and Fred (though Sirius was a blow). Hedwig almost had to not be around, because Harry and co were on the run for most of the last book - if Hedwig had been around it may have exposed them so in a way that was for the best. Dobby and Fred were both unexpected, Dobby going down defending Harry and thinking of George without Fred. (sob). Percy was the other one I was half expecting would die (as in the lead-up JK had apparantly said not all of the Weasley's would make it - obviously it wouldn't be Ron dying as JK had ruled that out). But since Percy had been on the outs with his family it would have just made it too tragic if he died the moment he reconciled with his parents. Reply #64. Feb 13 09, 8:55 AM |
gidday_mate
|
It started off with Sirius for me...than Dumbledore and then hedwig...moody aswell...they just kept dying...i didnt like to say any of the ones who died die...Fred most devestated me...especially how she finished the chapter... Lupin and Tonks was sad...because it made Teddy the orphan like Harry.... Snape's death was sad...because i always had a love hate relationship with his character...in the end it was love! Colin Creevey died also didnt he?? thats sad too... and poor Dobby...like someone else said that was a shock! too many were worse! Reply #65. Feb 17 09, 4:00 AM |
| gidday_mate
|
i also hated that Cedric had to die...i like him alot too! Reply #66. Feb 17 09, 4:01 AM |
LoonyLuna876
|
Anyone on the Good side, actually. But I was positively shaken by Fred's death. And Dobby as well(Notice, Dobby's first and last words in the series is Harry Potter!) I also cried when Dumbledore died, though i sort of expected it. But this is war; some sacrifices have to be made. They must pay a price, after all, to rid the world of Voldemort. Reply #67. Feb 20 09, 12:23 PM |
Binky-Jess
|
I thought it was really sad when hedwig died. Reply #68. Feb 22 09, 2:43 PM |
CoolTeen
|
Hmmm... Fred, Lupin, Tonks, Cedric, Sirius... all of them... Reply #69. Mar 12 09, 4:11 AM |
| RGRG4ever
|
It's like every book a person dies I cried when Teddy and Tonks Lupin die they left a great son and i cried when fred and good point not every weasly's would survice Reply #70. Mar 12 09, 5:25 PM |
aquato
|
probaly dumbledores Reply #71. Mar 12 09, 6:32 PM |
Bubnel
|
Sirius. Bye bye comic relief. Reply #72. Mar 17 09, 11:11 AM |
| LOTRluver
|
dobby, i cried quarts! Reply #73. Mar 18 09, 6:54 PM |
| midnig
|
I think Dumberdore was the worst. Reply #74. Mar 19 09, 9:39 PM |
| midnig
|
Then again mad eye was kinda shocking for a few of my friends. I talked some of my friends into reading all of the books.They loved it just like me. Reply #75. Mar 19 09, 9:43 PM |
bikoz
|
Fred's death was the least expected. I came near tears. Dumbledore's was ...well...understandable but sad. Reply #76. Apr 18 09, 6:38 AM |
detroyt05
|
I think killing off both Tonks and Remus was a little sad. Poor Teddy. Reply #77. Apr 27 09, 12:59 AM |
| CoolTeen
|
What if Harry died? LOL. Reply #78. Apr 27 09, 11:58 AM |
| WebsterWitch
|
Reading these made me get teary eyed again about some of these deaths. Hedwig was the worse for me because she had been with Harry since the beginning and was his only friend every summer while he was with the Dursley's. It was the first death that made me burst into tears. Dumbledore was sad and I cried, but Hedwig was so unexpected. sniff, sniff Reply #79. May 02 09, 6:46 PM |
| heypeople
|
Oh, let's see...I'd have to say Fred and Sirius. With Sirius, I was like so depressed. And with Fred I was like, "But he has a twin!" Poor George. Reply #80. May 03 09, 3:39 PM |
149 replies. On page 4 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: