Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 6 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
123laura123
|
Well, I love animals so Hedwig. Then Fred, Lupin and Tonks :( Reply #101. Feb 11 10, 11:21 AM |
gpm97457 
|
1. Sirius Black 2. Dumbledore 3. Fred Weasley 4. Dobby Reply #102. Feb 27 10, 11:07 PM |
Lush44
|
I think the worse (not the saddest) death was Wormtail. I dont think wormtail was a bad guy, he was just a coward. I liked the Rowlings gave him a "heroic" death. He just hesistated for one moment in his life to do the right thing...stupid metel Voldemort hand. Reply #103. Mar 19 10, 1:22 PM |
7PinKy7
|
I have read the first 3 books and saw two movies. I don't know much about Harry Potter. I do like how characters are being killed of. The thing I hate the most is when everyone or almost everyone live. Like The Lord of the Rings. I haven't read the book. In the movie really only two main good characters did. A couple of other characters did with good sized rolls. I wish there would have been a major death to someone. You fight all those battle and everyone walks away fine. Reply #104. Mar 20 10, 10:44 AM |
fanatic12
|
Definitely Dumbledore and Fred Reply #105. Apr 14 10, 7:33 PM |
naughty_trini
|
Dobby and Hedwig, I hated to see them go, they have been so loyal to Harry, they shouldnt have died :( Reply #106. Apr 15 10, 5:45 AM |
k00lperson
|
1. Dobby 2. Hedwig 3. Fred 4. Dumbledore 5.Lily 6.James 7.Sirius 8.Lupin 9.Snape 10.Wormtail 9. Reply #107. Apr 17 10, 7:50 AM |
reeshy
|
Hedwig :( It wasn't even important, plot-wise. I think JKR just went on a killing spree in the last book! Although, being a writer myself, I can't blame her much - I think I kill too many people in my writing, and I guess it was easier for her to make it final. Reply #108. Apr 21 10, 5:11 PM |
puffle23
|
dobby he had a knive thrown at hiim and alastor moody cause he been betrayed by mundungus fletcher and hit by a killing curse and fell off his broom.and harrys because he sacrificed himself but albus pervival wulfric brian dumbledore gave him a choice. Reply #109. May 22 10, 1:36 PM |
| GuruOfTrivia
|
Dobby, just because of how lovable he was. It's still sad every time read it, and that's saying something because you'd think that after 25 times I'd be numb to it! Reply #110. May 24 10, 3:06 PM |
evil44
|
The top ten worst deaths: #1: Dumbledore #2: Hedwig #3: Fred #4: Sirius #5: Tonks #6: Lupin #7: Snape #8: Mad Eye #9: Cedric #10: Colin Creevey Reply #111. Jun 16 10, 1:49 PM |
matthewpokemon
|
All deaths apart from Death Eaters. Would have liked to have seen the werewolf Fenrir Greyback killed, especially after what he did to the likes of Remus Lupin. Reply #112. Jun 23 10, 1:46 AM |
AdamM7
|
If Dumbledore hadn't died it might have ruined the plot, but I still think Dumbledore's death is the saddest. J.K. Rowling should of killed Malfoy and either Crabbe or Goyle, I can't remember which one died. ;( Reply #113. Jun 25 10, 10:32 AM |
| shooter0220
|
i think snape just because harry thought he was bad though the whole series but he sacarficed his life for harry... Reply #114. Jun 29 10, 5:10 PM |
| spamster101
|
Harry walking to death was awful to read a cried so much. Reply #115. Jul 28 10, 10:48 PM |
Jazmee27
|
Snape, Dobby, Hedwig, Dumbledore, Sirius, Tonks and Lupin Reply #116. Sep 24 10, 7:20 PM |
| coolguy10101
|
1.Dobby 2.Fred 3.Voldemort because when he died that marked the end of the series. 4.Sirius 5.Lily and James Potter Reply #117. Jan 06 11, 7:08 PM |
suntzu
|
Dobby and then I think Sirius Black Reply #118. Jan 15 11, 2:39 PM |
tobxan67
|
I don't think one of these is worse than the other but Tonks and Lupin leaving a child without both parents is so sad, then Creevey and Hedwig. Reply #119. Jan 16 11, 5:00 PM |
IAMMAGIK7
|
Snape was the worst for me. Always risking his life, and knowing he was good after all. All the deaths were sad. Even Voldemort, leaving this world not knowing love.:( Reply #120. May 05 11, 10:37 AM |
149 replies. On page 6 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: