Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 3 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
qbbman
|
I completly agree, Fred Reply #41. Sep 24 08, 1:45 PM |
srpolb3
|
hedwig i almost cried Reply #42. Oct 09 08, 2:10 PM |
jolana
|
Definitely, Fred. That was too much for me. Reply #43. Oct 09 08, 5:50 PM |
dodgermaniac88
|
Dumbledore's death was quite devastating Reply #44. Oct 12 08, 7:22 PM |
| vampyreslayer
|
The three people that died that made me cry my eyes out were Dumbledore, dobby and Fred. I loved those characters. Reply #45. Nov 08 08, 7:24 AM |
Chilax14
|
Hedwig and Fred because they were with Harry in every book. Hedwig was more sad to me though. Reply #46. Nov 14 08, 4:24 PM |
supersal1 
|
Fred, definitely. I knew one of the Weasleys had to go but I was rather hoping for Percy, after a dramatic and tearful reunion with his family. Reply #47. Nov 14 08, 6:10 PM |
AW3404
|
You may not agree, but I thought Wormtail deserved to live. He pretended he was dead and went straight back to Voldemort (that was bad) because Harry saved him from death. He realised that he was going to kill Harry and took his own life instead. Hedwig, Fred, Dobby, Mad-Eye, Lupin and Tonks were sad too. Reply #48. Nov 15 08, 2:25 AM |
esme11
|
Sirius's death was worse because he was the only nice member living of Harry's family and I almost cried, but then it has to be Hedwig because when he was lonely she was always there, from his first year. Reply #49. Nov 19 08, 2:24 PM |
| danjou
|
I disagreed with many things, but Fred's death as one of the least. I expected one of the twins to die in the "Final Battle" Reply #50. Nov 20 08, 5:02 PM |
| esme11
|
Same, but I didn't expect it to be whoever had their ear blown off because I thought that that was something horiffic for one of the twins and another thing would happen to the other. (Does that sound right?) Reply #51. Nov 21 08, 1:05 PM |
| wtfftw2
|
sirius is the worst to me but i think the one that affected the story most was dumbledor Reply #52. Dec 07 08, 3:20 PM |
| bananaphobia
|
Although you may not agree, but I would have to say greasy haired Snape. I do love the poor fellow. Reply #53. Dec 25 08, 9:53 PM |
| OMG_Pup
|
ooh yes. fred, dumbledore, and dobby =[ Reply #54. Dec 27 08, 4:38 PM |
| kit-kat24
|
well there is 4 that made me sad 1)dobby 2)lupin 3)tonks 4)fred Reply #55. Jan 05 09, 6:26 PM |
Cavaliersrock
|
So many people seem to have twins :P I have one too, we're identical twin sisters and so Fred dying was sad. Poor George. Also Dumbledore because he seems so invincible. But at least Dumbledore's death kind of went with the story. Fred's was just unneccesary. If Joanne makes anotehr book, she should make Fred a ghost or he just passed out and Voldemort come back, even though I actually smiled to myself when he died and Harry didn't. That sounds a bit mean... Reply #56. Jan 06 09, 2:01 AM |
baixinha
|
I agree with you, the worse death was Fred. Reply #57. Jan 08 09, 3:35 AM |
| KaTiEaNnE96
|
well i almost cried when hedwig and dobby died..i laughed when moody died and it was sad when fred died..snape deserved to die..but it was bad that tonks and lupin died and didnt get to see there son gro up Reply #58. Jan 08 09, 5:13 AM |
slytherinwitch
|
"snape deserved to die.." The total lack of capacity for love, forgiveness and tolerance expressed in this quote is astounding. As a character, Snape was horrified that Dumbles had plotted all along to lead Harry to slaughter. Snape shows far more compassion for a person he dislikes than the above statement does. I once had a literature teacher whose favourite comment was "literature teaches empathy." At times, though, I doubt it does. Reply #59. Jan 08 09, 12:22 PM |
dim_dude
|
Yeah, the worst would definitely be Fred. Still, it was a huge war and it would not have been so realistic if not one of the children died...so JK was right to kill at least one Weasley kid...once you think about it, what are the odds that they would all survive such a big war anyway? Reply #60. Jan 25 09, 2:39 PM |
149 replies. On page 3 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: