Subject: What death in the series was worse?
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
Posted by: GriffinLover
Date: Mar 15 08
I say it was so wrong JK killed Fred Weasley in the book.
149 replies. On page 5 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
goobas 
|
Snapes was the worst death. He had perhaps the saddest life and was the most courageous character in the series. Reply #81. May 06 09, 7:20 PM |
joanne_04
|
Fred was a fun loving character I hope it's not needed for him to leave the story. Poor George, he lost his twin Reply #82. May 13 09, 2:01 AM |
uc0nnfan92
|
I didn't like seeing Sirius or dobey die Reply #83. Jul 09 09, 5:27 PM |
| priya1234
|
i think its the death of fred,lupin and mad-eye moody and dooby made me cry like a baby....they shouldnt have died Reply #84. Jul 19 09, 10:05 AM |
wdstk
|
Dobby, I'm still crying over the little guy. He loved and was devoted to Harry. It's the one death that made me soooo angry with J.K. Reply #85. Jul 29 09, 11:12 AM |
Eebs
|
Hedwig. Killing animals (even fictional) depresses me. -Elizabeth Reply #86. Jul 29 09, 6:24 PM |
beergirllaura
|
Dumbledore, then Dobby, then Fred. Reply #87. Aug 14 09, 2:02 PM |
Dashiell_Parr
|
mine would be Sirius. He lost the only family he had that didnt hurt him. Reply #88. Aug 16 09, 1:52 PM |
skbirrell
|
Ok, I have to say this, of all the death's, the first that really wrenched me was Hedwig's. I know it's silly, but she had been with Harry since before any of them. However, Fred was worse. I am still devestated by that. I thought for a long while if there was a better person from the Weasley family to die, unfortunately I love them all. Reply #89. Aug 19 09, 10:30 PM |
jolana
|
I answered Fred earlier, but when I think of it, Cedric Diggory was the worst because he was the first and it came so unexpectedly and suddenly. Reply #90. Sep 07 09, 4:55 PM |
Jen_02
|
I would definitely have to say that Fred's death was a complete shock and one that I wish didn't happen. Poor George! Then Lupin, Hedwig and Dobby were others that I definitely cried over. Reply #91. Sep 12 09, 2:00 PM |
| 0babyangel0
|
I'd say hedwig...crid when she died :( Reply #92. Sep 30 09, 12:05 AM |
| 0babyangel0
|
voldemort...i like the bad guys, that a bad thing? :D Reply #93. Sep 30 09, 12:07 AM |
MyMoonMyMan
|
Snape's death is definitely the one that I cried the most over. But honestly, it's Remus Lupin's death that has me fuming mad. We don't even get to see him die! And we find out that he's dead by Harry walking by his and Tonks's body without so much as a remark. Reply #94. Oct 02 09, 7:35 PM |
| sarahcateh
|
Dobby and Snape made me cry the most. Reply #95. Oct 25 09, 9:18 PM |
| rfcneil
|
I personally thought that the worse death was Hedwig. She was with Harry throughout his magical life and was the only person that loved him while he was at the Dursley home. Reply #96. Nov 29 09, 4:18 PM |
halfbloodfreak
|
Sirius' death was the most tragic for me. I cry everytime i read that part or see that part in the movie. I mean really JK? Does the boy have to have a horrible home life untill he graduates? The most uncalled for death was hedwig. She was just a little bird! Lupin was my favorite defense against the dark arts teacher and i had a crush on the girl who played tonks in the movie. I could sit here and rant for hours about how all of the deaths affected me but these were the worst. Reply #97. Nov 30 09, 9:59 AM |
| roshio
|
Fred cause all I could think of was 'what about George'? I mean they were inseperable! Dumbledore as well cause he was like the last father figure Harry had, then she took him away as well? and also I love Dumbledore. Reply #98. Dec 30 09, 9:14 PM |
| 123laura123
|
Definitely Fred! I felt so sorry for George and remember in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix when Mrs Weasleys boggart was her family dead I really felt sorry for her too. And when all the dead bodies are in the Great hall and Mrs Weasley is crying over his body :( Oh, and Tonks and Lupin - poor Teddy! Reply #99. Jan 03 10, 10:59 AM |
astir
|
Hedwig for me, then Fred. Could see why some of the characters had to be killed off but didn't understand why those two were. Reply #100. Feb 05 10, 6:43 PM |
149 replies. On page 5 of 8 pages. 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8
Legal / Conditions of Use
|
|
: