| What's the Correct Order? | Choices |
| 1. (Season 2) | Jujubee |
| 2. (Season 3) | Monique Heart |
| 3. (Season 4) | Katya |
| 4. (Season 5) | Aja |
| 5. (Season 6) | BenDeLaCreme |
| 6. (Season 7) | Detox |
| 7. (Season 8) | Brooke Lynn Hytes |
| 8. (Season 9) | Chad Michaels |
| 9. (Season 10) | Alexis Mateo |
| 10. (Season 11) | Naomi Smalls |